On September 1, 2024, we celebrated a significant milestone: the 50th anniversary of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). Signed into law by President Gerald Ford on September 2, 1974, ERISA has quietly yet profoundly impacted the lives of countless Americans, ensuring that promises made regarding retirement and health care benefits are promises kept.

ERISA: A Commonly Overlooked Law That Impacts You

While the average American may not recognize the name, ERISA likely plays a crucial role in their lives. This landmark legislation sets minimum standards for most established retirement and health plans in the private sector, providing essential protections for plan participants and beneficiaries in employee benefits plans. From safeguarding retirement savings to ensuring that benefits regulations and requirements are adhered to, ERISA has been a cornerstone in the benefits industry for the past five decades.

A Journey Through ERISA’s History¹

The story of ERISA began with a series of broken pension promises that left thousands of employees without the benefits they were owed. The most notable case was the closure of Studebaker’s South Bend, Indiana plant in 1963, where workers were denied the pensions they were promised. This incident, among others, underscored the urgent need for pension reform and captured the public’s attention.

In response, President John F. Kennedy created the President’s Committee on Corporate Pension Plans in 1961,  which issued its report in 1962. Senator Jacob Javits introduced pension reform legislation in 1967, and the momentum continued to build, especially following the release of the 1972 Peabody Award-winning documentary, Pensions: The Broken Promise. Public hearings were held, legislative efforts advanced, and finally, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act was signed into law in September 1974.

Senator Javits, the principal sponsor of ERISA, described it as “the greatest development in the life of the American worker since Social Security.” ERISA has shaped how employers provide retirement and health benefits, working behind the scenes to set standards that protect millions of workers and their families.  ERISA was passed by the House in a vote 407 – 2 and unanimously approved in the Senate demonstrating how united the country was behind this important piece of legislation. 

The Evolution of Employee Benefits and Captives

ERISA’s influence extends beyond traditional employee benefits. Over the years, there has been notable growth in employee benefits provided through captives—specialized insurance companies owned by the businesses they insure. This trend has enabled companies to have greater control and flexibility over their benefits offerings while managing risks more efficiently. Not all benefits are subject to ERISA, as seen below, but if they are, they need to go through a filing process with the Department of Labor (DOL) to receive a prohibited transaction exemption (PTE). The goal of the PTE process is to ensure that the interests of plan participants in the captive model are still protected, through an additional layer of DOL oversight surrounding fair pricing and compliance.

As captives grow in popularity, they provide new opportunities for employers to offer competitive, tailored benefits while achieving cost control—a trend ERISA has helped enable by providing the regulatory framework necessary for captive expansion and innovation.

Looking to the Future: ERISA’s Continued Relevance

Fifty years on, ERISA remains as relevant as ever. A recent example of ERISA’s modern influence is the tentative approval given by the DOL to leverage a captive to fund pension plan risk for the first time. This development benefits both plan sponsors (employers) grappling with pension plan liability and benefits recipients.

As we navigate new challenges in the benefits landscape—from evolving retirement needs to the complexities of modern healthcare—ERISA provides a foundation that ensures the rights and protections of millions of Americans are upheld.

1 https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ebsa/about-ebsa/about-us/history-of-ebsa-and-erisa